Paper Mill Playhouse logo in gold
Now Playing West Side Story May 28 – June 28, 2026

Dine With Us

Restaurant Hours & Dining

Whether you are joining us for a spectacular pre-theatre dinner or dropping by for a post-show cocktail, we look forward to hosting you.

Standard Restaurant Hours (all non-performance weeks)

  • Wednesday – Thursday: 4:00 PM – 10:00 PM
  • Friday – Saturday: 4:00 PM – 11:00 PM
  • Sunday: 11:00 AM – 8:00 PM

Paper Mill Playhouse Pre-Theatre Dining

Experience our exclusive, curated three-course prix fixe menu during the designated dining windows below. 

Dinner Wednesday – Saturday 4PM – 6PM (7:30PM curtain)
Sunday 4PM – 5:30PM (7PM curtain) 
Lunch Thursday, Saturday and Sunday 11AM – 12:15PM 

Late-Night & Intermission Dining (Thursday – Saturday)

  • During the Show: Our à la carte menu remains available from the end of the prix fixe window until intermission.
  • Intermission: Stop by for a quick, refreshing to-go cocktail.
  • Post-Show Late Night: Join us after the curtain falls for late-night bites and craft cocktails until 11:00 PM. 

Reservations & Planning

Reservations can be booked directly online via Resy. Large parties are highly encouraged to book well in advance.

Planning ahead is strongly recommended, as local parking can become scarce immediately before showtimes!